https://www.channelfutures.com/wp-content/themes/channelfutures_child/assets/images/logo/footer-new-logo.png
  • Home
  • Technologies
    • Back
    • SDN/SD-WAN
    • Cloud
    • RMM/PSA
    • Security
    • Telephony/UC/Collaboration
    • Cable
    • Mobility & Wireless
    • Fiber/Ethernet
    • Data Centers
    • Backup & Disaster Recovery
    • IoT
    • Desktop
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Analytics
  • Strategy
    • Back
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Channel Research
    • Business Models
    • Distribution
    • Technology Solutions Brokerages
    • Sales & Marketing
    • Best Practices
    • Vertical Markets
    • Regulation & Compliance
  • MSP 501
    • Back
    • 2022 MSP 501 Rankings
    • 2022 NextGen 101 Rankings
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Galleries
    • Podcasts
    • From the Industry
    • Reports/Digital Issues
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
  • Channel Futures TV
  • EMEA
  • Channel Chatter
    • Back
    • People on the Move
    • New/Changing Channel Programs
    • New Products & Services
    • Industry Honors
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Advisory Boards
    • Industry Organizations
    • Our Sponsors
    • Advertise
    • 2022 Editorial Calendar
  • Awards
    • Back
    • 2022 MSP 501
    • Channel Influencers
    • Circle of Excellence
    • DE&I 101
    • Channel Partners 101 (CP 101)
  • Events
    • Back
    • CP Conference & Expo
    • MSP Summit
    • Channel Partners Europe
    • Channel Partners Event Coverage
    • Webinars
    • Industry Events
  • About Us
  • DE&I
Channel Futures
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Technologies
    • Back
    • SDN/SD-WAN
    • Cloud
    • RMM/PSA
    • Security
    • Telephony/UC/Collaboration
    • Cable
    • Mobility & Wireless
    • Fiber/Ethernet
    • Data Centers
    • Backup & Disaster Recovery
    • IoT
    • Desktop
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Analytics
  • Strategy
    • Back
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Channel Research
    • Business Models
    • Distribution
    • Technology Solutions Brokerages
    • Sales & Marketing
    • Best Practices
    • Vertical Markets
    • Regulation & Compliance
  • MSP 501
    • Back
    • 2022 MSP 501 Rankings
    • 2022 NextGen 101 Rankings
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Galleries
    • Podcasts
    • From the Industry
    • Reports/Digital Issues
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
  • Channel Futures TV
  • EMEA
  • Channel Chatter
    • Back
    • People on the Move
    • New/Changing Channel Programs
    • New Products & Services
    • Industry Honors
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Advisory Boards
    • Industry Organizations
    • Our Sponsors
    • Advertise
    • 2022 Editorial Calendar
  • Awards
    • Back
    • 2022 MSP 501
    • Channel Influencers
    • Circle of Excellence
    • DE&I 101
    • Channel Partners 101 (CP 101)
  • Events
    • Back
    • CP Conference & Expo
    • MSP Summit
    • Channel Partners Europe
    • Channel Partners Event Coverage
    • Webinars
    • Industry Events
  • About Us
  • DE&I
    • Newsletter
  • REGISTER
  • MSPs
  • VARs / SIs
  • Agents
  • Cloud Service Providers
  • Channel Partners Events
 Channel Futures

Telephony/UC/Collaboration


Is Switch Partitioning Feasible for CLECs?

  • Written by Channel
  • February 28, 1999

Posted: 03/1999

Carrier Channel

Is Switch Partitioning Feasible for CLECs?
By William H. Tucker

In a marketplace where a
competitive local exchange carrier (CLEC) is seeking efficiency, switch partitioning is
emerging as the fourth viable opportunity–behind bundled resale, leasing unbundled
network elements (UNEs) and network overbuilds–to more effectively serve its customers.

Not everyone embraces the notion of leasing switched minutes of use (MOU) from a
nonaffiliated company. Their concerns are legitimate. For one, it may involve leasing from
a direct competitor. Second, a CLEC may fear it will lose control of the customer; for
example, should a network problem arise, limited assurances exist that the customer will
be given the desired network priority. Third, while not technologically new, switch
partitioning represents a new type of wholesale product. This means that critical
contractual issues, such as pricing and terms, are not standardized yet. Finally, a host
of switching solutions and financing options are available from the larger switch
manufacturers as well as many of the smaller modular switch makers. The wide variety of
vendors and products allows a CLEC to acquire a switching solution tailored to fit its
customer and market needs.

Potential Benefits

Given these concerns, why would a CLEC even consider leasing switching from another
carrier rather than purchasing its own switch? Four primary reasons exist.

Improved Margins Compared to Bundled Resale

As nearly everyone agrees, bundled resale offers very limited opportunities at best to
generate positive operating margins. Most bundled resale discounts range from 15 percent
to 25 percent below retail. Add a requisite 10 percent (or greater) customer discount to
the end user, and it quickly becomes clear that any positive margins with bundled resale
will be very difficult to attain.

Additionally, with bundled resale, the incumbent LEC (ILEC) keeps the switched access
revenues. While switched access charges are the bane of the long distance industry, these
revenues are a boon to the CLEC industry. The benefit from either owning or leasing
switching is that switched access revenues accrue to the CLEC, and no longer to the ILEC,
thus significantly improving operating margins.

Quicker Market Entry

Leasing switching speeds market entry by enabling a CLEC to serve customers during what
is normally the provisioning cycle of the switch. Ordering and provisioning a switch
typically takes from nine months to a year or more. Through leasing, that cycle can be cut
tremendously.

One issue that must be addressed when leasing a switch is the interconnection status of
the switch leaser. To the extent that the leaser already has an interconnection
arrangement with a regional Bell operating company (RBOC), such as GTE Corp. or Sprint
Corp., it also is possible that the leasing company can ride those facilities and escape
the trunk-provisioning phase of implementation. Note however, that if the leaser does not
have interconnection, or if the leaser is unwilling to share the interconnection with the
leasing company, then the leasing company will be fully responsible for arranging new
trunks for interconnection. That process alone can take as long as six months. The best
time savings come when a company leases switching and interconnection capability as a
package.

Switch partitioning is not recommended for a CLEC that plans on purchasing a switch
within a year or so. The effort required to partition the switch, work out the operational
agreements, measure the traffic and subsequently migrate that traffic to its own switching
platform probably is not worth the effort in that time frame.

Fewer Up-Front Costs

Purchasing a switch typically requires a seven-digit investment. For markets where
market share may not support that level of capital outlay, partitioning a switch and
leasing MOUs can offer the benefits of owning facilities without the related large capital
outlay. Switch partitioning offers a pay-as-you-go approach for MOUs. For a CLEC with a
small customer base, the costs are lower, and as that CLEC gets larger, the costs increase
proportionally. Size does matter; eventually there comes a crossover point in which the
larger a CLEC gets, the fewer benefits it will receive from partitioning vs. ownership.

Entry into Small Markets

Many third-tier markets have attractive business prospects, but are not large enough to
support switch acquisition. Some markets already possess a glut of switch-based CLECs.
This may give a CLEC an opportunity to obtain very favorable switching terms. With bundled
resale offering minimal long-term opportunities for positive cash flow and markets often
too small or too crowded to justify switch purchase, leasing switching may allow the
necessary cash margin without the required capital investment.

Considerations

A CLEC that wants to entertain switch partitioning based on any of these potential
benefits needs to pay careful consideration to certain issues–namely pricing, contracts
and terms.

Pricing

Switch partitioning can be priced on a per-MOU basis, on a per-line basis or by paying
for services a la carte. On a per-MOU basis, there are two key considerations: a CLEC
pays for originating and terminating MOUs, not just originating; and a cap on
minutes per line is advisable to avoid paying for hours of customers’ dial-up Internet
time.

A per-line agreement limits exposure to high-traffic users. While it brings certainty
to switching costs, it is, in all likelihood, not a least-cost option. Many business
customers have limited local calling, and paying several dollars per line, per month may
be insurance, but it also may prove unnecessary.

Finally, a CLEC may want to carve out certain components of the switch and pay for
those separately. One example would be technical support, in which it may be better served
with a slightly lower switching rate while agreeing to pay for technical support on an
hourly basis. Other potential cost carve-outs include the initial provisioning work for
trunking as well as provisioning for the turn-up of new customers, disconnects and other
moves and changes.

Terms

Not only must a CLEC understand the price it will pay, but also more importantly, what
it is getting for its money. It is critical to know exactly what products and
services will be provided. For example, all standard features probably are included in the
price, but what about voice mail, remote call forwarding and rotary hunt? And how are
future generic upgrades handled? Does the cost include all new features associated with
all new generic upgrades? And if so, does the MOU cost increase as additional generics and
memory are added to the switch, or are capital upgrades included in the price? How are
items such as recording, signaling system 7 (SS7) transport and dips into the various
databases charged?

Another key item to understand is maintenance. As with an interconnection agreement, a
CLEC will want to establish trouble-resolution metrics and an escalation and notification
procedure. It is important to develop as much certainty as possible with respect to timely
response to customer concerns.

Related to maintenance are provisioning issues. How long does it take to program and
provision a line? And are there different time frames and costs between a line, a key
system trunk, a ground loop start trunk and a Centrex line?

A Real Strategy

Given these uncertainties, will switch partitioning ever make a substantial market
play? It is too early to tell. However, looking at the long distance marketplace as an
indicator, the answer is probably, "yes."

Long distance resellers make their living from purchasing switching and transport from
direct competitors. The issues listed above all have been addressed and standardized to a
large degree by that market segment. Most CLECs are still in a market-share acquisition
stage, and have not spent resources to develop a wholesale market presence for switching.
But at some point, switch-based CLECs will run into market share limitations, and will
start trying to utilize the excess capacity to cost-justify their very expensive switches.
When that happens, it probably will cease to be called switch partitioning, and simply
will be referred to as local minute resale.

William H. Tucker is principal for the Competitive Communications Group (CCG),
Riverdale, Md., a strategy consulting firm offering advice to carriers in the areas of
business development, operations, pricing, employee training and regulation. He can be
reached at [email protected].

Tags: Agents Telephony/UC/Collaboration

Most Recent


  • application portfolio modernization
    Adaptiv Networks' SD-WAN Joins OTG Consulting Portfolio
    Adaptiv Networks SD-WAN will help OTG agents move customers from PSTN to UCaaS.
  • partner portal
    GoTo Promotes Chief Product and Technology Officer to CEO
    He will accelerate innovation and growth in the SMB space, the company said.
  • Revenue, Sales Down
    Another Avaya Bankruptcy Pending? Company Launches Internal Investigations
    The company's stock price slipped all the way down to 61 cents per share on Tuesday.
  • Phishing
    Twilio Customers' Data Stolen in Phishing Attacks that Trick Employees
    The hackers impersonated Twilio's IT department.

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your Channel Futures account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • Sales Strategy
    Telesystem Promotes TBI, MetTel Vet to Channel Strategy Manager
  • Cloud Phone
    AT&T to Offer Up to 1 Million Customers Cisco Webex Calling
  • Sign a Contract
    Unisys Adds Managed UCaaS with $153 Million Unify Square Acquisition
  • Fortune 500 2021 logo
    AT&T, Microsoft, Verizon, More Tech, Telco Companies Make Latest Fortune 500

Upcoming Events

View all

MSP Summit

September 13, 2022 - September 16, 2022

Channel Partners Conference & Expo

May 1, 2023 - May 4, 2023

Galleries

View all

Black Hat USA 2022: DNSFilter, NetWitness, BlackBerry, CrowdStrike, More

August 10, 2022

Samsung Unpacks Galaxy Z Fold4 Foldable Phone with Multitasking PC Features

August 10, 2022

Images: Telarus Hosts Partner Summit, Gives Partner, Supplier Awards

August 5, 2022

Industry Perspectives

View all

Seize the Application Modernization Opportunity

August 2, 2022

A Growth Mindset: Your Organization’s Strategic Differentiator

August 1, 2022

Timely Tips for Non-Negotiable Patch Updates

July 29, 2022

Webinars

View all

Outsmarting RaaS: Implementation Strategies To Help Your Clients Before, During, and After a Ransomware Attack

August 23, 2022

Why it is Important to Upgrade Aging Servers and How to use Live Optics to Upgrade Efficiently

August 25, 2022

Executives at Home are Not Alright: An Intro to Digital Executive Protection

September 8, 2022

White Papers

View all

Work Goes Remote – (and Other Top ITOps Trends)

May 25, 2022

The New Bottom Line: How MSPs Can Meet the Healthcare Crisis While Evolving Their Businesses

April 19, 2022

How to build a Security Operations Center (on a budget)

April 4, 2022

Channel Futures TV

View all

ThreatLocker Preaches Zero Trust, Addresses Industry Competition

ScienceLogic Debuts New Partner Portal

August 9, 2022

Vonage a ‘Single Communications Stack Provider’ for Partners, Customers

June 27, 2022

IBM, Partners and the $1 Trillion Hybrid Cloud Opportunity

June 26, 2022

Twitter

ChannelFutures

Read about @adaptivnetworks's new distribution partner. dlvr.it/SWQFh3 https://t.co/az12SeMU7X

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

A succession crisis has been brewing in the channel. Are you thinking about how to develop leaders?… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

Looking for clues about the upcoming #Rackspace #restructuring? We have a little insight from yesterday’s earnings… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

Ready for more @GoogleCloud in #AsiaPacific? Find out where channel partners will be able to take advantage of new… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

[email protected] has been a key figure in both the TSB market and the channel DE&I community. @Telarus… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

.@SamsungMobileUS launches new #GalaxyZFold4 and Galaxy ZFlip 4 at #SamsungUnpacked. dlvr.it/SWP38j https://t.co/nY6KLrk1E4

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

#BHUSA kicks off with news from @DNSFilter, @NetWitness, @BlackBerry, @CrowdStrike, more. dlvr.it/SWNvrj https://t.co/oDI6vf5CdX

August 10, 2022
ChannelFutures

Get to know @ScienceLogic and its new channel leader ahead of @MSP_Summit. #MSPSummit @Channel_Expo… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

August 9, 2022

MSP 501

The industry's largest and most comprehensive partner awards program.

Newsletters and Updates

Sign up for The Channel Report, Channel Futures Update, MSP 501 Newsletter and more.

Live Channel Events

Get the latest information on the next industry-leading Channel Partners event.

Galleries

Educational slide shows and images from live events.

Media Kit And Advertising

Want to reach our audience? Access our media kit.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • Channel Partners Events
  • Telecoms.com
  • MSP 501
  • Black Hat
  • IoT World Today
  • Omdia

WORKING WITH US

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter

FOLLOW Channel Futures ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X